Blog

Understanding the Essence:

A key point to grasp is that Krishna allows no place for mere beliefs. He is not offering mystical fantasies or rigid instructions but is leading Arjuna to a truth that arises from self-inquiry and direct understanding. Too often, popular interpretations reduce the Gita’s message to a set of fixed rules, infusing them with personal biases. In reality, Krishna’s words are meant to provoke a personal revelation—a process where one questions, understands, and then lives by that very understanding.

The Verse in Focus

Let us now examine verse 2.47 of the Bhagavad Gita:
 कर्मण्येवाधिकारस्ते मा फलेषु कदाचन |
 मा कर्मफलहेतुर्भूर्मा ते सङ्गोऽस्त्वकर्मणि ||
 Translated by Swami Vivekananda as:
 “You have the right to work only, and not to the fruits of work. Let not the fruit of action be your motive, nor let your attachment be to inaction.”

Addressing the Dilemma:
Krishna anticipates this very thought and cautions, “Let not your attachment be to inaction.” On one hand, he is asking not to do action for the sake of results and on the other hand, he is also warning against the tendency for inaction.

What he is really saying is that in our day-to-day lives, we have complete control over our actions—but not over the outcomes, which depend on innumerable external contingencies. Attempting to manipulate or control the result leads only to mental turmoil and incomplete performance of our chosen action.

The Dual Centers of Action:
Consider that there are two centers from which one’s action can emerge. The first judges an action solely by the results it produces. Given the multitude of unpredictable external factors, such judgments are inevitably flawed and coincidental. The second center evaluates an action on its own merit—the inherent righteousness of the act itself, independent of any external reward. The first approach makes one mentally dependent on outcomes, resulting in constant worry and sleeplessness. The second path, however, offers inner peace because one is confident in having done what is right, regardless of the result.

When we focus on the inherent merit of our actions, every act becomes complete in itself. The satisfaction does not come from a future reward but from the knowledge that we have chosen the right action to do. Even if results affect us to some degree, they do not have the power to alter our commitment to what is right.

Defining Right Action:
Krishna’s teaching on Karma Yoga emphasizes that the right action originates from self-knowledge. It is an action not dictated by dogmas, blind desires, or conditioned tendencies, but one that springs from an inner center of understanding. This understanding is reached only after a process of rigorous self-inquiry—a process that cuts through all layers of absorbed conditioning and personal biases. In this way, the emphasis shifts from the end result to the merit and righteousness of the action itself.

Rejecting Fatalism:
Through this verse, Krishna also challenges the notion of fatalism. If everything were predetermined by fate, then the idea of having a right to one’s actions would be meaningless. Krishna’s words clarify that while our actions are within our control, the results are shaped by innumerable, often random, contingencies. Rather than being enslaved by a fatalistic outlook, one is encouraged to act rightly for its own sake.

However, this is not to say that Krishna is asking to renounce fruits of the action. As clear from the verse itself, he says no such thing. He is just explaining an eternal law, something no one can control. Results of an action are dependent not just on our action, but on so many other variables. Thus, the one who acts only for the results will have to accept the subordination of these forces. Whereas one who acts for its own sake isn’t bothered by these forces.

Final Words:
In concluding our discussion, it is important to remember that our journey to understand the wisdom of the Gita is ongoing. The text is not a set of commandments to be followed blindly but a profound guide that invites us to question, understand, and then live by that understanding. Its true value lies in its power to provoke self-inquiry and foster a deep, personal realization of truth.

As Krishnamurti once said, “When I understand myself, I understand you, and out of that understanding comes Love.” In the same way, understanding the essence of our actions helps us to act rightly and live a life unburdened by the unpredictable outcomes of our efforts. This is the heart of its enduring relevance and its profound impact on our lives.